Does I-732 Really Have a “Budget Hole”?, Sightline Institute report on the I-732 Washington State carbon tax ballot initiative, Aug. 2.
Brookings report on state carbon taxes is a winner
The Brookings Institution is out with a handsome new report, State-Level Carbon Taxes: Options And Opportunities For Policymakers. We’re still digesting it, but it looks like one of the most lucid and useful publications on carbon taxes to appear in a long time. At a minimum, it’s essential reading for at least two (overlapping) groups: people seeking to advance carbon taxes at the state level, and people who want to steep themselves in the nuts and bolts of implementing actual carbon taxes.
The authors are three heavy hitters in carbon tax policy and advocacy: Adele Morris of Brookings, Yoram Bauman of Carbon Washington, and David Bookbinder of the Niskanen Center. Together they bring to bear key disciplines (economics, law, political organizing), extensive knowledge, and keen interest. It’s no surprise their report is a winner.
Here’s the start:
Much has been written about the design of a federal-level carbon tax. This paper adapts these findings to the state level, motivated by pending federal regulations (which place implementation obligations on states), policy discussions in states with commitments to ambitious long-term emissions targets, and state budget shortfalls that could necessitate new revenue. Notwithstanding the myriad political impediments to a carbon tax, this paper explains how state policymakers can design one to fit their fiscal, economic, distributional, and environmental goals.
They find that “a $20 per ton tax on energy-related CO2 emissions could raise up to 2-3 percent of state GDP in the most emissions-intensive states.” That is significant, they say, because current state revenue instruments — sales, property, income, and business taxes — typically collect only about 5% of GDP. Moreover, contrary to the usual view that a carbon tax might be an unreliable revenue generator, if only because the revenue base of carbon emissions would shrink over time, the report concludes that carbon fees could prove less volatile than other state revenue sources.

Graphic is from Brookings issue brief (see link at end).
While carbon fees of $20/ton are almost certainly far lower than the levels needed to fully drive the transition of the U.S. economy to a low-carbon base, it’s a reasonable level for considering state taxes, given issues of leakage, interstate competition, and poorly diversified state economies. In any event, the report’s insights into state carbon tax implementation don’t depend on any particular tax level.
For all 50 states plus the District of Columbia, annual revenues from applying $20/ton state-level carbon taxes to all fossil fuel combustion would total $106 billion, based on 2013 emissions and assuming, for simplicity, zero price-responsiveness. That’s around two-thirds of one percent of combined state GDP. But the range is enormous, from a low of around 0.3 percent (for California, Connecticut, and Massachusetts; here we exclude DC, for which the tax revenue would equate to just 0.05% of GDP), to more than 2 percent for North Dakota and West Virginia and more than 3 percent for Wyoming. (See graphic; Wyoming was inadvertently omitted.)
Tellingly, of the 15 states with the highest shares of potential carbon tax revenues relative to GDP, 14 are “red” on the political map. Only New Mexico voted for a Democrat, President Obama, in 2012 (and 2008). The correlation of carbon-dependence with electoral conservatism underscores (and reflects) the political polarization over climate belief and carbon-reduction policy. And while organizing for state carbon taxing has been exclusively focused on low-carbon blue states such as Washington and Massachusetts, the sheer fiscal potential of carbon taxes in the states shown in the graphic suggests vast untapped potential to transform state economies from fossil-fuel extraction to a broader and more sustainable base.
The Brookings report is far richer than mere figures and graphs. It dives deeply but clearly into thorny questions like interstate transport of fuels and electricity, and harmonizing of state carbon fees with EPA Clean Power Plan requirements, that haven’t arisen at the federal tax level. Issues of federal pre-emption (e.g., for aviation fuels), compliance with the “dormant” Commerce Clause of the U.S. Constitution, and revenue usage are treated as well. The report is also richly referenced and annotated.
Whether or not the path to a U.S. carbon tax will need to wind from one or a few early-adopting states to Congress can’t be predicted. Regardless, the Brookings report is both a masterful summation of state carbon tax issues and a vital read for anyone pursuing carbon pricing in the United States.
Link to the full 32-page Brookings report: State-Level Carbon Taxes: Options And Opportunities For Policymakers
Link to the Brookings issue brief (contains graph shown above): What to consider when designing a state-level carbon tax
Elon Musk’s Powerful Case for a Carbon Tax
Nov. 2 addendum: Read Musk’s carbon tax pitch, transcribed from Leonardo DiCaprio’s new climate change documentry, Before The Flood, at bottom.
Visionary inventor-entrepreneur Elon Musk is constantly in motion. Last week he was in Nevada checking on his Gigafactory, which purportedly will be the world’s largest-footprint building (as big as 107 football fields) and make enough batteries each year to power 1.5 million Tesla Model 3s. Yesterday Musk revealed his intention to merge Tesla Motors and SolarCity — a $2.6 billion wager that Tesla owners will use those batteries to store power from SolarCity panels.
This is big business, big climate and big vision rolled into one. Large-scale deployment of batteries could let solar and wind resources dominate electricity production without need for carbon-emitting grid support by fossil fuel plants. Replacing gasoline-powered autos with electrics will almost certainly squeeze carbon emissions out of transportation faster than biofuels or other low-carbon liquid fuels.
In Nevada, Musk also spoke up for carbon taxes, though hardly for the first time. Four years ago, for example, at the Wall Street Journal’s ECO:nomics conference in Santa Barbara, CA, Musk disparaged tax credits for green cars and declared that “the best method for addressing climate change in the automotive industry is to impose a tax on carbon dioxide emissions,” according to the trade journal plugincars. But what he said last week was so richly detailed and articulated that it deserves to be quoted in full.
As reported by Benjamin Spillman in the Reno Gazette-Journal, Musk was asked whether the Gigafactory would have been economically viable without over a billion dollars in state incentives, plus federal tax credits for electric vehicles and solar panels. He replied:
[I]f you accept the scientific consensus[,] every oil burning activity is subsidized, dramatically. If you believe there is a value to the CO2 capacity of the atmosphere and oceans and that CO2 capacity is not being paid for by the price at the gas pump or the coal that is being burned for electricity generation or whatever its use may be then every single fossil fuel burning activity is massively subsidized.
After reminding his Nevada audience that climate change “has become sort of an ideological issue because there are people who think that global warming is not true,” Musk continued:
[A]ll we are doing [with a carbon tax] is trying to match the inherent subsidy for fossil fuels . . . on the sustainable energy side. Fossil fuels are already getting a massive subsidy if you believe in global warming. If you don’t then [the subsidy] seems really unfair. If you do then it is like oh we are just trying to correct it.
But Musk was just warming up to the carbon taxing subject:
The real right way to correct [the subsidy] would be to establish a carbon tax. If you ask any economist they will tell you that is the obvious thing to do, put the correct price on carbon because we currently have an error in the economy which misprices carbon at zero or something closer to zero. It is a fundamental economic error.
He then turned to the supposed conflict between libertarian ideology and taxation:
For people that have a sort of libertarian bent they get a little confused. . . They need to appreciate the high level principle of why they are opposed to government intervention. They are actually opposed to government intervention because it causes false pricing. If the government says we are going to massively incent the production of corn, so that effectively corn gets mispriced and we make too much corn, that . . . does not benefit the country if you make too much of something because of a government driven pricing error . . . That is sort of what people with a libertarian bent are opposed to.
However if you have . . . an unpriced externality [with] the CO2 capacity of the oceans and atmosphere priced very close to zero then any government action to increase the price above zero reduces the error in the economy. [What libertarians] should actually be opposed to is anything that increases the error in the economy, a pricing information error. So pricing carbon, if you believe in global warming, does not increase the price of the error it decreases the price of the error.
Spillman tweeted these remarks, and Musk retweeted his approval:
The libertarian argument for a carbon tax https://t.co/WmbGp2YuUO
— Elon Musk (@elonmusk) July 29, 2016
Whether or not you identify as libertarian, you should savor Musk’s bracing clarity on (and for) carbon taxing. Maybe in time, other solar and wind advocates will bolster their customary pleading for subsidies with their own clarion call for carbon taxing.
Addendum, Nov. 2, 2016: Musk did a star turn in support of carbon taxes in the Leonardo DiCaprio climate docu, Before The Flood. This transcript is courtesy of EcoWatch. The film is up on YouTube through Nov. 6. Afterwards, only in theaters.
DiCaprio is in the Nevadan desert visiting the “gigafactory,” the latest project of Tesla founder Elon Musk. Once at full operation by 2020, the vast factory aims to be producing annually 500,000 electric vehicles and batteries/cells equal to 85 GWh/yr. Musk explains why this could be a game-changer:
Elon Musk: What would it take to transition the whole world to sustainable energy? What kind of throughput would you actually need? You need a hundred gigafactories.
Leonardo DiCaprio: A hundred of these?
Elon Musk: A hundred. Yes.
Leonardo DiCaprio: That would make the United States…
Elon Musk: No, the whole world.
Leonardo DiCaprio: The whole world?!
Elon Musk: The whole world.
Leonardo DiCaprio: That’s it?! That sounds manageable.
Elon Musk: If all the big companies do this then we can accelerate the transition and if governments can set the rules in favour of sustainable energy, then we can get there really quickly. But it’s really fundamental: unless they put a price on carbon…
Leonardo DiCaprio: … Then we are never going to be able to make the transition in time, right?
Elon Musk: Only way to do that is through a carbon tax.
Should We Care that Clinton Isn’t Pushing a Carbon Tax?
The conventions are over, the country is pivoting toward the Nov. 8 elections, and Dave Roberts, Vox’s energy and climate blogger, is out with a post insisting, yet again, that “a carbon tax is not some magical climate cure-all.”
Roberts has said this before, many times. We (CTC) even posted a point/counterpoint with him after he poured cold water on carbon taxes in 2012, after Hurricane Sandy. Now, with so much going on — a glass ceiling-shattering nomination by the Democrats, a civil society-threatening nomination by the Republicans — should we care?

Does it matter that neither candidate advocates a carbon tax?
We should. For one thing, Roberts is an influential journalist; here’s NY Times superstar columnist Paul Krugman linking to Roberts last summer. For another, a carbon tax shattered its own vault of silence in the Democratic primary season; after Bernie Sanders’ unapologetic calls in speeches and the debates, advocating a tax on carbon emissions isn’t necessarily a ticket to political oblivion. Moreover, Roberts’ post today raised questions about a carbon tax’s magnitude that are worth addressing.
What set Roberts off this time was a recent editorial in Technology Review that chided the Democrats for “ignoring the one thing that could best help curb carbon emissions.” That thing is, of course, a carbon tax. The TR editorial dutifully blasted Trump’s climate denialism and the GOP’s labeling coal a “clean energy source,” and then said:
But the Democratic platform might not be meaningfully better. Although Hillary Clinton has a climate change plan, and it is supportive of President Obama’s Clean Power Plan (which is held up in the courts), and makes broad promises to cut subsidies for the oil and gas industry, it leaves out one big thing: a carbon tax. (emphasis added)
That last bit was too much for Roberts. Clinton’s energy plan, he wrote, would
- expand solar and other clean alternatives.
- increase US energy efficiency by a third and decrease US oil consumption by a third within 10 years of her taking office.
- aim to meet or exceed the carbon reduction target Obama promised in Paris: 28 percent under 2005 levels by 2025.
Roberts continued:
Clinton has said exactly how much carbon her plan would reduce. Would a carbon tax reduce more? It obviously depends! A high carbon tax would. A low carbon tax wouldn’t. A revenue-neutral carbon tax that reduces the income tax would be different from a carbon tax that funds clean energy deployment… The effects of a carbon tax depend entirely on its size and implementation details.
There’s some truth there. But let’s go further.
To begin, saying how much carbon you hope to eliminate isn’t the same as having a plan to eliminate it. And unless we’ve missed something, Clinton hasn’t spelled out how she’s going to cut oil usage by a third.
Spurred by plunging prices, U.S. consumption of petroleum products in 2015 rose for the third consecutive year and is now within 7 percent of the 2005 peak. (To see for yourself, download the latest Monthly Energy Review and navigate to Table 3.5, “Petroleum Products Supplied by Type,” totals column.) Without a stiff carbon tax that not only steers purchases away from SUVs and pickups but also counteracts the resumed trend of more miles driven, there’s no way the ambitious (on paper) Obama-Clinton fuel-economy standards can bend the petroleum curve sharply downward, as we’ve written here.
Indeed, our own modeling suggests that even a robustly rising carbon tax that reached triple digits in its tenth year would only cut oil usage from the 2005 peak by a quarter.

A briskly rising carbon tax can cut emissions fast and far.
The chances of achieving a 28 percent cut in economy-wide CO2 emissions by 2025 are brighter, partly because 2015 emissions were already 12 percent below the year-2005 benchmark. And our model predicts that a triple-digit carbon tax would, in its tenth year, be cutting CO2 emissions by 40 percent below emissions in 2005. As the Republican candidate remarked about a different type of performance, “I guarantee you there’s no problem” — provided the tax is high enough, as our graphic shows.
But that’s with a carbon tax. Without one — or some economy-wide carbon price — it’s difficult to see how the U.S. can progress from 12% below 2005 currently, to 28% below by 2025, as we wrote in 2014, following the announcement of the historic U.S.-China emissions pact. The picture is probably little different today, insofar as the positive changes since then — coal’s accelerated demise and the rapid uptake of ever-cheaper photovoltaics — are being undermined by the rise in usage of cheap oil.
There you have it: while the Clinton energy plan may be great for solar, it doesn’t map a path to deeply cut oil use and carbon emissions. In contrast, an economy-wide carbon tax — and here Dave Roberts is right, the tax must be robust, even steep — can do both.
Did Technology Review hyperventilate when it said that without a carbon tax, the Democratic climate stance in the election “might not be meaningfully better” than the Republican? Yes, somewhat. But let’s let the Pulitzer Prize-winning fact check site Politifact have the last word.
Two months ago, Politifact fact-checked this proposition: “Bernie Sanders says only he supports carbon tax and [an] ‘aggressive’ approach to climate change.” It rated Sanders’ claim — not just that he alone among the candidates supported a carbon tax but that his climate change approach was aggressive — “mostly true.”
That’s not to say we want Clinton to call explicitly for a robust carbon tax this fall. That’s a political calculation best left to others. But let’s be clear among ourselves of her climate plan’s shortfall vis-a-vis the task at hand.
Carbon and other greenhouse gases should be taxed at a rate high enough to spur the transition away from fossil fuels consistent with the temperature goals agreed to in Paris in 2015.”
Resolution by insurgent Democratic Party platform committee members led by Bill McKibben that was narrowly defeated in St. Louis in late June.
Only Climate Darkness at End of GOP Tunnel?
The Republican Convention is over. And it’s fair to wonder if the dream of a bipartisan carbon tax is over as well.
It’s not just the viciously hard-right emotions and ideologies so prominently on view in Cleveland. While those are disturbing enough, they could perhaps be written off as convention fever. But we can’t ignore the persistent absence of palpable climate concern in virtually the entire Republican Party.
Consider A Cure for Trumpism, the high-minded essay by two leading “reform conservatives” that led the New York Times’ Sunday Review section on the eve of the convention. Stretching over 2,000 words, this blueprint for a revitalized Republican Party, by Times columnist Ross Douthat and National Review editor Reihan Salam, never mentioned climate change or global warming. There’s also the strange case of Jay Faison, the plutocrat whose ClearPath Action Fund, the Times informed us in June, “will spend at least $2 million on digital media campaigns to defend [Republican] Senate incumbents running in two of the tightest races in the country, Rob Portman in Ohio and Kelly Ayotte in New Hampshire.” That’s in “recognition of the senators’ support for clean energy,” Faison told the Times. “ClearPath is also spending several hundred thousand dollars on digital advertising campaigns to support Representatives Carlos Curbelo of Florida and Tom Reed and Elise Stefanik of New York, all Republicans running for re-election in similarly tight races,” the Times noted.
Since Faison routinely lambasts the Obama Administration’s Clean Power Plan as too regulatory, you would think he backs invisible-hand approaches like taxing carbon. Not so, according to this account in the Daily Caller:
North Carolina philanthropist Jay Faison has come out against taxing carbon dioxide emissions as a conservative solution to both fighting global warming and promoting cleaner sources of energy.
“We don’t need more subsidies and top-down regulation,” Faison told reporters [on March 8] at the National Press Club. “[M]aking traditional energy sources, like coal and natural gas, more expensive is not the way to power innovation in green energy.” (emphasis added)
That’s a zinger, all right — correcting the massive market failure that is unpriced climate pollution means more “top-down regulation.”
So what climate solutions does the GOP’s great green hope support, if not a carbon tax or other price mechanism? Here’s the Daily Caller again:
Faison argued [that] more needs to be done to get rid of burdensome regulations on hydroelectric dams and nuclear power plants.
There you have it. Precious few Republicans are willing to publicly support carbon taxing, even in revenue-neutral form. Either climate pales beside real issues like immigration, family-friendly tax reform and foreign policy (Douthat & Salam), or we can cure it, somehow, without resorting to carbon taxes (Faison).
What about the Republican rank-and-file? Evan Lehmann of ClimateWire was at the GOP convention and he spoke about climate with some 51 GOP delegates. Here’s how he distilled their responses:
A Texas delegate tilted his hat back when asked about climate change and said, “Ew.” A delegate from Florida lamented his party’s inaction on warming. And one from Wyoming claims it’s a conspiracy to hide the government’s involvement in the spread of a damaging beetle.
The bad, the good, and the ugly, you might say. (That beetle infestation, by the way, which is devastating lodgepole pines throughout the Rockies, is itself largely a result of climate change.) Not exactly the stuff of a party steeling itself for taxing carbon emissions — or taking any concerted action on climate.
We could also cite the failure of even a single House Republican to vote against the Scalise Amendment denouncing a carbon tax. And that was in June, after any of them might have had to fear a primary challenge for veering from party orthodoxy.
Their rationale could be Koch Brothers money, or resentment of scientific elites, or, as writer Rebecca Solnit has suggested, an “ideology of isolation” that militates against grasping the interconnectedness at the heart of ecological thinking. Another factor, hinted at by former GOP House member Nan Hayworth in an interview with the Guardian this week, is that Republicans, having ceded the climate issue to Democrats, are now loath to be identified with it:
My former colleagues understand the importance of protecting the environment, but one of the problems is the political opposition from environmental groups and the left is so extreme in some cases, even when they try to move towards environmental points of view they get no credit for it politically.
Really? Republicans would get no political credit for backing effective climate action? With head-spinners like that, it’s hard to disagree with the suggestion last week by veteran Times columnist Tom Friedman that “the best thing that could happen to America [is] that Donald Trump is not just defeated, but is crushed at the polls.”
Friedman was envisioning a “sweeping victory” in which the Democrats not only keep the White House but retake Congress, giving them “a chance to put in place a revenue-neutral carbon tax” without needing a single GOP vote. Whether November goes that way is anybody’s guess, but today’s Republican Party is so tied up in anti-climate knots that it’s hard to see a bipartisan path to the only policy that can drive down emissions fast and far.
Carbon Tax Works: CTC’s New Carbon Tax Model
We’ve just posted the annual update to our spreadsheet model — our powerful but easy-to-use tool for predicting future emissions and revenues from possible U.S. carbon taxes. The model, which runs in Excel, accepts any carbon tax trajectory you feed it and spits out estimated economy-wide emission reductions and revenue generation, year by year.

Stiffer tax means steeper reductions. Our model quantifies the relationship.
Here’s what’s new:
1. A year of new data: The most obvious update is our incorporating 2015 baseline data on energy use, CO2 emissions and emission intensity for each of the model’s eight sectors.
2. Oil refining made explicit: We’ve added an eighth sector: oil refining. Until now, refinery emissions were lumped with “Other Petroleum Products,” which was too broad-brush, especially considering that they accounted for an estimated 6.4% of U.S. CO2 emissions last year. Refinery fuel use now has its own sector. This not only trims the catch-all “Other” category, allowing greater precision; it also ensures that future changes in use of gasoline, diesel, jet fuel and other petroleum products are carried through the supply chain to yield emission changes in the refining process, not just at the exhaust pipe.
3. Sharper graphics: The graphics in this post are among the dozen with which the spreadsheet conveys the rapid reductions from robust carbon taxes, especially vis-a-vis well-meaning but limited policies such as the Obama Administration’s Clean Power Plan.

Our updated model has lots of graphics.
4. Emissions consequences of cheap oil: While the model is baselined to official U.S. forecast energy prices (from the Energy Information Administration’s “Annual Energy Outlook”), the current version is the first in which the 2015-2016 oil price slump reverberates for many years. The lower baseline price projections for gasoline and other petroleum fuels don’t change the predicted impact of carbon taxes on demand for those fuels, but they do establish a higher usage trajectory than in previous years, underscoring the need for a robust carbon tax.
As a reminder, here are two key features we added last year:
1. Smoothing the carbon tax impact: The model can reflect lags in households’ and businesses’ adaptation to more-expensive fossil fuels. The user sets the adaptation “ceiling” rate; the model automatically carries over any excess to future years.) This feature is helpful for trajectories like the Whitehouse-Schatz bill, which kicks off with a bang at $45 per ton of carbon dioxide but then rises only slowly. Under our default setting, in which the economy is assumed to react in any year only to tax increments up to $12.50 per metric ton of CO2 ($11.34 per short ton), the reductions from that initial $45/ton charge are spread over four years rather than, unrealistically, assigned to the first year.

Results are for tax that rises annually at $12.50 per metric ton of CO2.
2. Demand impacts vs. Supply side impacts: At the bottom of the Summary page is a new section comparing the projected CO2 reductions from changes in fuels’ carbon intensities (“supply side”) versus reductions from reduced energy usage (“demand side,” e.g., lower electricity purchases, less driving or flying). Under our default carbon tax — the one proposed by Washington Rep. Jim McDermott — an estimated 58% of projected CO2 reductions are on the supply side (i.e., due to decarbonization); a large minority, 42%, come about through reduced demand, illustrating that subsidies-only policies miss out on huge CO2 reductions. Indeed, they undercut reductions from decarbonization by stimulating energy usage through lowered energy prices, as we pointed out in our 2014 comments to the Senate Finance Committee.
Please download the spreadsheet — here’s the link again — and run it in Excel. See for yourself the relative efficacy of a carbon tax trajectory that increases by a fixed amount each year, as does the McDermott tax, vs. one like Whitehouse-Schatz that starts high but rises only by small, percentage-driven amounts. See also how much more quickly emissions decline under either carbon tax scenario, compared to the Clean Power Plan and other regulatory policies forced on the Obama Administration by the recalcitrant Republican-controlled Congress.
As you work (play?) with the model, jot down your thoughts so you can tell us what works and what needs improving. Thank you.
Note: graphic at top has replaced similar graph that (confusingly) expressed carbon tax in terms of annual increments.
Time for Climate Advocates to Move Beyond the Clean Power Plan
The U.S. power sector is racing past the Clean Power Plan’s emissions target. It’s time for climate advocates to do the same.
Too many climate advocates seem to be investing the Clean Power Plan — the Obama Administration’s project to achieve a 32 percent shrinkage of U.S. electricity-sector carbon emissions from 2005 to 2030 — with iconic significance.
We can understand why: power generation from fossil fuels, primarily coal, was responsible for almost 42 percent of total U.S. CO2 emissions in 2005, more than double the share of the next sector, passenger cars.
And we at the Carbon Tax Center will grant that the administrative machinery set in motion by the Clean Power Plan may have accelerated the shift in power generation from coal to natural gas and, secondarily, wind and solar, although that shift was already in high gear before the plan was unveiled two years ago (see chart), driven by cheap and abundant fracked gas and the ongoing renewable-tech revolution.

Real climate action requires a much tougher target.
But the CPP target — a 772 million metric ton drop in annual emissions from electricity generation by 2030 — is already in sight, nearly a decade ahead of schedule. Since 2005, the plan’s baseline year, electricity emissions have fallen (as of 2015) by 518 million tonnes. Ten years in, and with 15 years to go, we’re two-thirds of the way to the goal line. On the past-decade trendline, the target will be met in 2021.
The 2005-2015 rate of decline in power-sector emissions is so far ahead of the CPP that it could be cut by two-thirds going forward and the 32 percent reduction goal would still be met.
The math is elementary, but it bears emphasis in light of the discussion swirling around last week’s debate in St. Louis over the effort of the Bernie Sanders – Bill McKibben forces to ramp up the climate-policy language in the Democratic Party’s 2016 platform. This is from Ben Adler’s take in Grist:
The Clinton campaign says its reluctance to accept some of McKibben’s amendments reflects legitimate concerns about the policy implications, not mere political calculation. Not all experts agree that a carbon tax is the most effective way to reduce emissions, for example. Mary Nichols of the California Air Resources Board had pointed out in her testimony to the committee a week earlier that a carbon tax does not guarantee emissions reductions, while direct regulation, such as Obama’s Clean Power Plan, does.
Former Bill Clinton and Obama official Carol Browner also leaned heavily on Nichols’ testimony in her remarks in St. Louis in leading the charge that narrowly defeated the McKibben carbon tax, as we noted in our recent post on the debate.
The irony of course is that the Clean Power Plan didn’t actually “guarantee” much of anything, insofar as the plan’s targeted reduction has been happening more or less on its own.
But if power-sector emissions are falling so easily, why bother with a carbon tax at all?
For a lot of reasons. Here are the key ones:
- First, the U.S. needs to blow way past a 32 percent shrinkage in power-sector emissions over 25 years.
- Second, non-electricity emissions of CO2 — now 63 percent of the U.S. total — have fallen little, dropping from 2005 to 2015 by just 190 million metric tons as electricity emissions were falling by 518 million. The majority of those emissions are from gasoline, diesel, jet fuel and other petroleum products, underscoring the importance of offsetting the nearly historically low petroleum prices that businesses and consumers are “enjoying” today and banking on in the future, with carbon taxes.
- Third, we need to shrink not just emissions but the financial and political power of the oil industry. We’ve got to break the cycle that allows fossil fuel corporations to lock in policies — including the “right” to dump greenhouse gases into the atmosphere at no charge — that lock in demand for their product. A carbon tax will help crack that open.
We’ve never underestimated the difficulty of enacting robust carbon taxes in our nearly-closed political system. One piece in many to get us there faster is for the climate movement to see that the Clean Power Plan is yesterday’s plan. As we argued in our prior post, the core of our plan going forward must be Bill McKibben’s carbon tax resolution from St. Louis:
Carbon and other greenhouse gases should be taxed at a rate high enough to spur the transition away from fossil fuels consistent with the temperature goals agreed to in Paris in 2015.
Note: The data underlying our graphic may be found in CTC’s carbon-tax spreadsheet model (Excel file).
Last Week’s Democratic Platform Vote Was a Win for Carbon Taxes
“Carbon and other greenhouse gases should be taxed at a rate high enough to spur the transition away from fossil fuels consistent with the temperature goals agreed to in Paris in 2015.”
That’s the carbon tax resolution that environmental activist Bill McKibben pressed the Democratic Party Platform Drafting Committee to adopt at its meeting in St. Louis last week. The proposal lost 7-6, as did allied resolutions opposing fracking and investments in fossil fuel infrastructure. Still, the vote is the latest step by carbon taxing on its march into the political mainstream.

Carbon tax campaigner: 350.org’s McKibben
Befitting McKibben’s gift for concision, the resolution was scarcely longer than a tweet. But it spoke volumes: carbon emissions must be taxed; ditto, other greenhouse gases like methane; and the tax must be high enough to catalyze an energy revolution. Note also what the resolution did not say: that carbon should be “priced,” an expression that, though useful in its place, can be a weasel word allowing for cap-and-trade schemes. No, the proposal specified a carbon tax, straight up and robust.
Two Congressmembers on the panel were equally unambiguous:
- “Taxing carbon is the most effective way to reduce carbon emissions. It will offset the massive societal cost of unchecked carbon emissions.” — Barbara Lee, California 13th CD
- “This is a very market-y proposal. Companies aren’t internalizing all their costs, they’re externalizing them onto the rest of us. Shouldn’t they be responsible for covering the cost they impose on us? I think yes.” — Keith Ellison, Minnesota 5th CD
Those are pretty sophisticated arguments. Less so was this objection from Hillary Clinton surrogate Carol Browner:
The concern we have about a carbon tax is that it won’t necessarily achieve reductions. It will generate revenue, but it won’t necessarily achieve reductions because some companies will simply pay the cost. And what we want, and what we think is absolutely essential, is measurable reductions of carbon pollution in the air.
If it’s measurable reductions Browner wanted, she could have cast her eye at British Columbia, where a “starter” carbon tax of just $20 per ton of CO2 cut emissions in its first four years, although those cuts have stalled out, predictably enough, as the tax level stopped rising.
And anyone with a basic grounding in economic policy analysis will see right through Browner’s argument. Those hypothetical “companies [that] will simply pay the cost” of high-carbon energy won’t be around for long; they’ll be supplanted by enterprises that can provide electricity, manufacturing and transport more cheaply because they’ve heeded the carbon price signal and switched from dirty energy to untaxed clean fuels and efficiency. Households and businesses will also adopt sustainable practices that gain cost-effectiveness as the carbon tax takes hold.
Read our follow-up post, Time for Climate Advocates to Move Beyond the Clean Power Plan.
Bizarrely, Browner based her canard about carbon taxes — that they generate revenue rather than cutting carbon — in part on the failure of California’s cap-and-trade system. Presumably, Browner, a prime Democratic Party environmental apparatchik for over two decades, knows better. One can only imagine McKibben’s frustration as he saw carbon taxes tarred with the cap-and-trade brush.
Needless to say, Bill isn’t backing down, as he made clear in his post-mortem in Politico calling out the Clinton campaign for “obstructing change” by locking up the Democratic Party platform. While we’re sad that the carbon tax resolution didn’t pass, we’re pleased that McKibben not only drafted but fought hard for it.
Carbon tax proponents have long seen the logic in having Bill advocate for carbon taxes. Taxing carbon pollution jibes perfectly with the agenda of 350.org, the organization he has built into a formidable global grassroots force. No other policy tool both undermines the profitability of the fossil fuel industry and also leverages divestment (financially and culturally) from that sector.
McKibben’s leadership for carbon taxing in St. Louis — and, hopefully, beyond — is both heartening and important.
To View the Platform Committee Debate: The entire (10-hour) debate is on YouTube. McKibben’s opening argument starts at 5:39:20. Barbara Lee’s remarks begin at 5:45:25 and Keith Ellison’s at 5:45:50. Carol Browner’s objections begin at 5:47:30.
Analee Graig, an undergrad at SUNY-Binghamton, contributed reporting to this post.
Can These Ads Get Republicans to Act on Climate?
The curtain is up on a series of pro-climate action ads in that climate-denialist stronghold, the Wall Street Journal editorial page. Four ads are up, with eight more to follow by mid-July, produced and paid for by the center-right advocacy group, Partnership for Responsible Growth.
A good deal of craft has gone into the ads, along with a bundle of money — that space doesn’t come cheap. It’s fair to ask what the payoff might be.

Four ads are up, eight are coming soon. Click the link in the top line of this post to read them without squinting.
Presumably, the objective is to help induce a critical mass of G.O.P. Congressmembers to support meaningful carbon-pricing legislation, before it’s too late. A president alone can’t implement economy-wide carbon pricing, and barring a broad leftward upheaval in November, at least one chamber in the next Congress will still be Republican.
Getting a few dozen Republicans to break ranks and support a carbon tax would overcome the House Republican bias baked into the electoral math. A bipartisan bill would also give cover to Democratic Senators and Reps from coal states and exurban counties — there are still some left — whose votes would be needed as well.
Of course, that’s been the situation since the G.O.P. took the House in 2010. Cynics who pronounced carbon taxing dead under a Republican Congress have been proven right — thus far. Yet some facts are changing, and not just in the air, with global-average temperature records breaking monthly. Solar and wind electricity in the U.S. now generate more than twice the electricity, jobs and dollars they produced half-a-dozen years ago, with much of that in red states. A low-carbon or even zero-carbon world can’t be written off as a pipe dream.
Those are political facts. Interestingly, three of the four Journal ads thus far are limited to scientific ones: “Carbon Dioxide Traps Heat On Earth,” proclaims Ad #2. “The Earth Has Warmed And We Did It,” says #3, followed by #4, “What Goes Up Doesn’t Come Down.”
True, the emphasis will change if, as we hope, the series builds to a call for a briskly rising (and revenue-neutral) carbon tax. If so, the initial ads will have been conversation-starters. That would be fine, ordinarily. But while we were taking notice of the ads, the July Harper’s arrived, with a provocative essay by the activist-writer Rebecca Solnit that makes one ask if the series ventured off on a good foot.
Solnit’s essay, The Ideology of Isolation, is an unflinching critique of extreme right-wing thought. It begins:
If you boil the strange soup of contemporary right-wing ideology down to a sort of bouillon cube, you find the idea that things are not connected to other things, that people are not connected to other people, and that they are all better off unconnected. The core values are individual freedom and individual responsibility: yourself for yourself on your own.
Any student of ecology, or anyone with a passing acquaintance with John Muir, the 19th century explorer-mountaineer-naturalist who founded the Sierra Club, can see where Solnit is going: the ideology that insists we’re not connected to each other, save for a contingent series of market interactions, is the same ideology that denies the interconnections that make up ecosystems and indeed the physical world.
Muir’s glittering aphorism, “When we try to pick out anything by itself, we find it hitched to everything else in the universe,” demands we pay attention not just to flora and fauna but to the megatons of heat-trapping gases we’ve been sending skyward since the dawn of the Industrial Revolution. In contrast, the right-wing ideology of disconnection doesn’t just give us license to ignore our effluent, it practically requires that we do so. Solnit again:
On a more fundamental level, the very idea of climate change is offensive to isolationists, because it tells us more powerfully and urgently than anything ever has that everything is connected, that nothing exists in isolation. What comes out of your tailpipe or your smokestack or your leaky fracking site contributes to the changing mix of the atmosphere, where carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases cause the earth to retain more of the heat that comes from the sun, which doesn’t just result in what we used to call global warming, but will lead to climate chaos.
The central meme in ad #2, that the greenhouse effect “isn’t a left or a right issue, it’s science,” may be sweetly reasonable, but the reader has to believe in science in the first place. As Solnit notes,
If you begin by denying social and ecological systems, then you end in denying the reality of facts, which are after all part of a network of systematic relationships between language, physical reality, and the record, regulated by the rules of evidence, truth, grammar, word meaning, and so forth. You deny the relationship between cause and effect, evidence and conclusion, or rather you imagine both as products on the free market, which one can produce and consume according to one’s preferences.

“When we try to pick out anything by itself, we find it hitched to everything else in the universe.”
And if those preferences are for the riches and influence that come from owning and exploiting fossil fuels, the resulting facts and science won’t lead ineluctably to the position that climate change is real, occurring and principally man-made. In that scenario, the Partnership’s carefully crafted ads may simply bounce off Journal readers and fall harmlessly to the ground.
To be sure, a campaign as professional as the Partnership’s Journal ads isn’t necessarily seeking to change minds through education. The mere fact of the ads — the idea that Republican backers and lawmakers are being addressed on climate from the center-right — is at least as likely to move the political needle as the logical thread in the text.
All the same, there’s another scenario kicking inside the Beltway — we heard talk of it in DC this month — that suggests that a healthy if not House-regaining shellacking by the Democrats will compel the G.O.P. to finally divest itself of its anti-science brand; and that accepting the reality of climate change and a “Republican solution” in the form of a carbon tax could be part of that reformation.
That scenario might have pointed to a more overtly political approach, though that may be where the Partnership’s series is headed. Meanwhile, the initial set may be viewed here. What do you think?
- « Previous Page
- 1
- …
- 27
- 28
- 29
- 30
- 31
- …
- 171
- Next Page »
